2019 Audi RS5Sportback
Deal Analysis
Standard · 4/6/2026You're looking at a 2019 Audi RS5 Sportback asking $109,005, and the data presents a clear warning: this is not a good deal. The asking price sits 120% above the market median of $49,625—a $59,380 gap that's difficult to justify even for a well-maintained performance sedan.
Three factors dominate this analysis. First, the valuation disconnect is severe. Comparable vehicles are selling for roughly half the asking price, suggesting either significant overpricing or undisclosed issues that would explain the premium. Second, the depreciation trajectory is brutal. The car's estimated current value is just $38,000 according to the BCV, meaning you'd be paying nearly 3x what the market actually values it at. Third, the hold score of 0.1 out of 100 reflects this reality—the market is sending a clear signal that this asking price doesn't represent value.
The vehicle itself carries no open recalls and has reasonable maintenance costs at $2,500 annually, so the asset isn't fundamentally compromised. The problem is pure pricing. You're also working with limited dealer visibility, which adds friction to any negotiation.
Before proceeding, your single most important action is to request a detailed explanation from the seller for why this car is priced so far above market comps. Ask for service records, accident history, and any modifications or special provenance that might justify the premium. If none exists—and the data suggests it won't—use the $49,625 median as your negotiation anchor and be prepared to walk.
9 more sections available with Starter