Veblen
2023 Porsche 911 Carrera S — photo 1

2023 Porsche 911Carrera S

$220,02920,000 micargurus
22Pass

Deal Analysis

Standard · 4/6/2026

You should pass on this acquisition. This 2023 Porsche 911 Carrera S fails your investment criteria at the gate level, and the numbers make the case unambiguous.

The asking price of $220,029 is fundamentally disconnected from market reality. Comparable vehicles are trading at a median of $64,249—meaning you're being asked to pay 242% above market. The current estimated value sits at $75,355, which means this car has already depreciated roughly 66% from its original asking price. That's not a negotiation gap; it's a pricing error or a serious misunderstanding of the market.

The second critical issue is mileage. At 6,667 miles per year, this vehicle exceeds your standard gate threshold of 6,000 annually. For a 2023 model, that's a meaningful pattern that compounds depreciation risk and increases your long-term maintenance exposure—$3,000 annually in routine costs alone.

On the positive side, the vehicle carries no open recalls and has a clean safety record. But that's table stakes, not a reason to buy.

The dealer's credibility is also unclear. You have no Google rating, review count, or visibility into their franchise status or funding structure—which matters when you're dealing with a $220,000 price tag.

Your next step: Walk away from this listing. If you're interested in this model year and specification, use the median comp price of $64,249 as your actual market anchor and source vehicles priced within 5-10% of that range. The market for 911 Carrera S models is deep enough that you don't need to chase overpriced outliers.

9 more sections available with Starter